The Peddler Of Fake Akalabeths Has Struck Again!

Sadly, I was on a plane when Stephen Emond alerted me to this eBay sale, which is almost certainly a scam, and so was unable to post about it before sales on the item finished. I greatly pity the “winner” of the auction, who is now out over $1,300 on an item that is almost assuredly fake.

Which, by the way, would be this:

[singlepic id=2556 w=550 h=550 float=center]

Akalabeth on tape. TAPE!

Now, as a general rule, we can probably just take the good Mr. Emond’s word for it that this copy of Akalabeth is, well, a fake. I mean, [amazonify]1467934607::text::::he should know[/amazonify], right? A cursory glance at the auction page also gives reason for caution, such as the seller’s assertion that he found this item at a “Military-Surplus Flea-Market” in “1994”. Or his warning about the integrity of the package:

Item “SOLD AS IS” due to Untested condition, lack of necessary hardware/knowledge & long storage period, over 15 years.
Could be only good for retro Data restoration enthusiasts or arrive “DOA”-Dead On Arrival, unsure :-/

Which is really a lot of words with which to say “I will be sending you a blank tape.” But since there is still a tiny measure of plausibility to all of the above, Stephen Emond also suggests having a read of this Google Groups discussion, which gives the known history of the tape version of Akalabeth. Because as far as anyone knows, there was one copy made on tape, because that was the media that Richard Garriott intended to use to distribute the game. And he still has that one copy, which became obsolete with the advent of floppy disks (which happened just as he was looking to release the game). Heck, he even had it framed.

As far as anyone knows, including Garriott by his own assertions, there were no additional tape copies made. Which means the odds that a second tape copy somehow a) was made and b) turned up in a flea market are terrifyingly low.

Which, in turn, means that someone probably just got swindled out of $1,300…and more. Damn.

7 Responses

  1. CmdrFalcon says:

    Thanks Ken, the real credit here goes to the guys in the SW Collect group who have a great talent for sniffing out these fraudulent auctions. I’m just sorry I wasn’t able to get the information to you sooner.

    I’d long suspected that Richard had only created the Akalabeth tape as a one-off mock up before distributing them on disk. He did have extra stickers made though so other copies were a possibility. Howard Feldman, a longtime game collector and highly trusted source was able to confirm the cassette history from Richard directly:

    “When I made the game… there was NO disk drive.
    So I planned to ship on tape!
    Then the disk drive came out, so I of course used that.
    I have the 1 tape final version here at my office, framed.
    I think I have some of those stickers too…”

    The seller was identified as “Manuel Carillo” from Brownsville, TX. The forger of a number of other recent Akalabeth / Ultima items was “Jacob Carillo” of Brownsville, TX. He stopped using his previous eBay account (likely after being banned) hence the new one having only 2 feedback.

    While unfortunately too late for this auction, please let this be an important lesson in vigilance for everyone. Akalabeth in particular is incredibly easy to forge and well worth the effort for devious scumbags since they command such highest prices.

  2. Sanctimonia says:

    Link should be:

    https://groups.google.com/forum/#!topic/swcollect/dagWnMxygSY

    “The seller is Manuel Carillo from Brownsville, TX. The forger of the
    Appleoids, Akalabeth, etc. was Jacob Carillo of Brownsville, Tx.”

    Why don’t we start a Kickstarter project to sue the shit out of this asshole? After finding an attorney we’d need to subpoena eBay and PayPal (same entity I think) so the perp could be identified. If it gained traction, I don’t see why Richard Garriott or others in the know wouldn’t give their two cents as experts. Hell, EA/BioWare might even contribute.

    I don’t care what kind of disclaimers are in the ad, this is fraud and is criminal. If we were ex military we’d be pissed when some civilian conned people by lying about their service, so why should this be any different? These people are pissing on our favorite game to the emotional and financial detriment of our fellow fans. Justice, Honesty and Valor cry for blood while Compassion and Humility sit and watch.

  3. Sanctimonia says:

    CMDRFALCON: You posted while I was still writing. 🙂 I respect your vigilance. What do you think about actually pursuing action against these vermin?

  4. CmdrFalcon says:

    While I’d personally love to see guys like this get the snot beaten out of them, I’m hoping we don’t need to fire up the torches just yet. I’m not sure what kind of recourse is available through Paypal but I’d assume if the seller can prove the item was fraudulent (as many of us flagged the auction as) and the seller can be tracked back to those other auctions he should have no trouble recovering his money. He’d also have fantastic grounds for a lawsuit.

    The seller (particularly in the older auctions) wrote VERY lengthy descriptions about how he found these incredibly rare items from but had absolutely no interest in proving their provenance, etc. I can see that shielding him on one or even two auctions but this is an obvious pattern of deliberate fraud. If the buyer needs any help digging up additional evidence on this guy I’d be more than happy to assist.

  5. Sanctimonia says:

    The buyer can file a claim with eBay and/or PayPal, but the buyer must first know if they were scammed. They may not know yet, and we don’t know for sure how many different buyers there have been. There does seem to be a pattern of abuse as you said, which makes it a bigger case. Maybe submitting a bunch of evidence tied together by a cover letter to the district attorney of the accused’s residence would be better than a civil complaint for damages. Let the state handle it but monitor them to make sure they’re at least doing something (supplying more evidence or testifying in court or by video if necessary).

    A plea or jury would decide if the accused knew they were doing something wrong. It would also be cool to have a YouTube video of an Ultima fan standing up in open court as a witness against a fraudulent antique dealer, pointing and saying, “That is the man who sold me my fake Ultima stuff.” Would be very funny.

  6. Odkin says:

    I’m beginning to question the authenticity of my original Akalabeth CD-R.